Monday, January 21, 2013

Back in the Swing?

Ahhhh We're two weeks into second semester and things are moving SO slowly!
The first week was torture, second week was just quick awful death, and this week is just merciless.
But, February has two national holidays so two long weekends in an already short month.
Before Christmas, I just kept telling myself to make it to Christmas.
Now, I just keep telling myself to make it until March.
Once I get through February, it'll be smooth sailing, right?

One interesting thing recently was that a group of Americans from DC came. They were in a group called GOA - I have no idea what it stood for, but they have something to do with the Compact Agreement between the US and RMI. They were here checking out health and education and basically trying to see how the money has been spent and what they can do to help things. After their visit they will write a report and send it to Congress sort of advising them on where to go from here.

It was weird seeing and talking to ribelles. Especially government worker ribelles. We actually sat down and talked to one of them about how the school runs and everything and what some of the issues are and it was clear she had the view that these people were beneath her. Sivoki was in the meeting with us and I felt like this woman kept talking to her like she's slow or something, I was getting really frustrated. It's upsetting to me how anyone could come here and feel superior to these people. They are not stupid or dumb - they are absolutely as capable of everything we are, they just choose not to. It's so hard to explain this place. One thing that came up kind of was just how the Marshallese are used to living off the land - you don't need an education for that (I think this was something that Sharlen and I were talking about, not something that came up in this meeting). But that right there is a huge part of the problem here. This culture has never thought of education as being all that important because they never used to need it and now, all of a sudden, people are trying to say that it is important, but most people either don't understand why, or have never see in what way it can be important, so why bother?

The problem here in Ebeye is that there are too many people and not enough land. Even if this atoll went back to "living off the land," there isn't nearly enough land to support all of the life here. But there also aren't that many opportunities for jobs either, so there's still not much need for an education. This place is a disaster.

I just wish that the Japanese and Americans had never come to this place. We took a beautiful, amazing, idyllic culture/people/place and completely ruined it.
And the Marshallese hold no ill will or resentment to us for it. I think that's the part that makes me feel the worst.

Though, I should say, that is only one side of it. On the other hand, the Marshallese have let us come in and pervert their culture and they love having American goods and food and imports and everything, so they aren't entirely innocent, but being here and seeing what their culture is like - that's just how they are. They welcome everyone. I don't think they ever expected Western influence to change their lives, but it has. And it's changed them in ways that they can't sustain here.
It's just sad.

Not exactly where I expected this post to go... Sorry. End rant.

1 comment:

  1. Think office in question was GAO (Govt Accounting Office). Yes, they can be rather arrogant. Essentially, they write reports for Congress. Normally, they interview other government employees. If their findings reflect poorly on your organization (and that finding is traced back to you and something you told them), your life can get pretty miserable.

    I understand your thoughts on US essentially changing the world for the Marshallese but what was the alternative? If the US or other more develped nations never came into the islands, there would be no modern medicine (lot higher rate of infant deaths - reaching the 1st year birthday would again be more than symbolic), no opportunity to learn via reading or to learn math skills beyond basic arithmetic, no opportunity to travel, no electricity, no telephones, etc, etc... Exposure to all of this changed expectations - unavoidable.

    Back in the 1960's when the US was still the Trust administrator, the UN very strongly criticized the US for not doing anywhere near enough to prepare the RMI (and the FSM and Palau and CNMI) for eventual independence. That is what led to a massive effort to build from scratch schools on all the outer islands, to the establishment of utilities, and to all the other infrastructure projects. The Peace Corps also came in large numbers and further changed attitudes and expectations.

    There is lot, lot more to this but, in end, if the majority of Marshallese did not hunger for all these things, they would not move to Ebeye, to Majuro and to the United States. No one is forcing anyone to stay on Ebeye.

    Other cultures have adapted to changes in the world and "moderninity"; other customs in other countries have changed. Yet, for Marshallese, any change to traditional practice seems to be extremely difficult. Yes there are Marshallese (likely a majority of the Iroij and Leroij and some Alabs and their families) who are very happy with current practices and customs/traditions and actively oppose any effort to implement any change. That said, there are elites in all countries that resist change - what makes the RMI (and to a lesser extent, the FSM and Palau) different?

    I believe one unforseen negative consequence of the Compact is that potential "change agents" have decided it is much easier to emigrate to the United States and live there permanently vice remaining in the Marshall Islands and working to make needed changes. Why risk your well-being and that of your family to the wrath of the powerful when you do not have to. Any Marshallese with the money to buy a one-way plane ticket can immediately put all the issues behind them by moving to the United States. Only a heroic few, knowing they have this option, choose to remain in the Marshall Islands. There are not enough of these folks to get changes done.

    Finally, and related, many thought that Marshallese who moved to the US would (as people from the Philippines and Tonga and other nations do) send money back to their brethern and that would lead to improved conditions on Ebeye and Majuro and the Outer Islands. That has not happened - and why should it, since you can send your relatives a one-way plane ticket to the US instead? And the more working age relatives you bring over who get jobs, the more that money that goes into the family "departure from the RMI ticket buying fund". No citizens in any nation, except the Compact nations, have this option.

    ReplyDelete