I started posting a new status on Facebook and before I knew it, it had turned into a rant.
And I realized that I was making comments on the entire World Teach Marshall Islands program, with only my experience and Sharlen's in mind.
What I started to say was, as I continue doing these Professional Development Modules for World Teach, I am realizing more and more that I am not cut out to be a good teacher.
I can teach, no problem.
But actually being good at it?
Not so much.
At least not with ESL.
I am sure teaching in the States would be a bit easier, but I can't do anything like this.
Professional Development Modules require us to read an article relating to a certain area of teaching, whether it be creating a good lesson opening or closing, introducing new material, or classroom environment and dealing with problem behaviors. There is a very wide variety of topics covered.
One thing I keep finding though is how much balancing a teacher has to do.
Every article gives several strategies on how to be most effective.
In a year of teaching, you have to find out which strategies fit best for your classroom.
And the strategies may differ between classes.
Not only that, you have to constantly assess the level that your students are working at and you have to remember their levels.
Then you have to consider not only how to teach material, but how to engage your students in it, and you have to find ways that engage all students, not just some. And again, this may be different for every section you teach.
I am incapable of keeping track of all of these things.
I have had some amazing teachers and I am striving to embody them... but I am unable to be effective with every class section I teach.
I am exhausted every day.
I feel unmotivated and at times, honestly, flat out depressed at my inability to reach my students.
I have tried almost every method I have come across in these modules and sometimes they work and sometimes they don't, but it changes with every student and every class and I can't keep track of what has worked well and what hasn't with which group.
I am not good at this.
And maybe I wasn't meant to be good at it.
But I'm just sad.
I feel like I've let my kids down.
Much as they drive me insane, they really do feel like my kids.
They will always be my kids and I will always remember them with fondness.
(Well, some of them. Some of them I will be pretty happy to never see again quite honestly).
A huge part of me wishes that I didn't hate teaching here. I wish that I didn't miss my family so much. I wish that I felt like staying a second year would be a good idea.
If I stayed, I could be so much better at this next year. I would make a great second year teacher, I think. If I knew next year all that I've learned now, I could be so much more effective.
But even though that is true, I still miss my family and I want to go home. I still don't have the support from the principal that I need to be effective in the school. There is still not enough funding, or appropriate resources. And there are still so many problems in this school system that will not be solved no matter how good I am at teaching.
I don't think I could handle it another year.
I really don't.
I tell myself that I can get through this year because God is with me, and I know that He is the only reason I've made it this far.
But I also don't feel any sense of conviction that I should stay either.
And I believe that there is a reason for that as well.
Maybe some day I'll come back and try again.
Maybe some day I'll get more training in ESL teaching and I'll try to become better at it.
I realize that my strengths as a person do not include teaching in a large group setting.
I am so much better one on one or in a small group.
I will have to keep that in mind for future career choices.
I feel bad. These PDMs are supposed to be helping us improve throughout the year... It's just making me realize how inadequate I really am.
This program is at the most grassroots level and what the Marshall Islands needs more than anything are good, experienced teachers who are capable of the multitasking required and the mental capabilities necessary to keep track of 100+ students. That is just not me.
Those people who are truly committed to teaching and recognize it's importance and want to be truly good at it, I recommend a year of service as an ESL teacher. These places need trained teachers, not people like me.
I was happy to get accepted into this program and I feel blessed to be here, but from the very beginning I have questioned what on earth made me seem like a good candidate, and after being here all this time, I still ask myself that question. I am not good at this. I am not cut out for this. It has been by the grace of God that I haven't left yet.
I've got one quarter left and I've never felt more unmotivated.
Because, I know, with complete certainty, that it truly is a waste and it will not make any significant impact.
At least not in their education or understanding.
I'm sure my kids are learning something.
But it's not whatever I'm trying to teach them.
Just a couple quick notes, that I hope help put your experience in perspective:
ReplyDelete• You may enjoy reading this blog, from a missionary/teacher at Baptist-sponsored school on Majuro. I suspect she is having an easier time than you but sure some of what she relates will be familiar. http://godsadventure1.blogspot.com/
• The Marshall Islands is desperate for qualified teachers; this article highlights this long-term situation and U.S. government decision that enough time has been given for Marshallese to rectify. http://www.rnzi.com/pages/news.php?op=read&id=74978
• And finally, when I was living in the RMI, the US Peace Corps was still a major presence – and all the Peace Corps volunteers were teachers. The Peace Corps began support to the Marshall Islands in 1967. Then, with virtually no warning, the Peace Corps left in 1996. In spite of several initiatives by the Government of the Republic of the Marshall Islands and others to bring the Peace Corps back to the Marshall Islands, to date there has been no return. Interestingly, the Peace Corps remains active in the Federated States Of Micronesia. I have never read an explanation of why the Peace Corps left the Marshall Islands but I suspect reports by Peace Corps members about their experience teaching in the Marshall Islands had a significant influence on this decision.
. . .I might also suggest you are, I believe, being much too critical of your capabilities as a teacher of ESL.
ReplyDeleteI suspect in a different setting, with different cultural context (Korea, as very opposite culture example) that your view on your ability (and enjoyment) of the ESL teaching experience would be much different.
You have learned that you are not a good match for prevalent attitutes of Marshallese students in a public Marshall Islands school. Based on WT in Marshall Islands blogs I have been able to follow over the years (most of which end in a month or two after three or lesss entries), few if any volunteers find the experience to be what they expected and hoped.
If living overseas was your dream, suggest give one more try in a different setting before deciding that really not for you.
What if this last quarter isn't about the kids? What if it's about you and what God has to teach you? Have faith, Haley...I'll have faith on your behalf :-). I'm so proud of you and the way you have followed The Lord through this whole year and stuck close to Him! THAT is a success :-). You are incredible! Keep me updated how I can be praying for you and supporting you this last quarter! I love you!
ReplyDelete